Science is also the most entertaining class I have to grade. As a student, essay questions were the bane of my existence; however, as a teacher, they provide me with great laughs in my office as I read students' attempts to explain or diagram earth science concepts.
One test I gave ended with an essay question: students could choose either to explain the way gravity works or draw a map using the key components of a good map (legend, scale, compass rose, etc.).
Those who chose to reflect on gravity offered some very insightful observations. For example, Fernando stated that "Gravity is very important because if nothing holds you down to the ground everything would be floating and unorganized." Sounds like the thoughts of someone in the early stages of obsessive compulsive disorder.
Lana added to Fernando's sentiments with a vivid real life image when she wrote "Gravity is very important, we can't live without it. If you are on a farm and you're planting plants you can't really control anything. Everything gets away from you." Can you imagine the chaos that would be caused by a lack of gravity on a farm?! All the seeds would just float away, right along with Bessie the cow and the farmers wife. How disorganized!
For Fakher, the disorganized results of a lack of gravity were to be assumed, along with just about everything else we can know about gravity. That must be why he chose to use the ever so useful term "etcetera" in his answer. The fact that English is Fakher's second language is also evident: "The gravity works from the weight. It is air, it works from the weight it effects etc. From lighter etc. in a good shape." I gave him one point for connecting gravity to weight, although I'm still not sure what he is saying here.
Of those who chose to draw a map there are two notable mentions. Mark, who is quite artistic, did very well. He drew each floor of the high school and even included the basketball court in the "Jim."
Next there is Amir. Amir is one of my favorite students because he is so lovable and funny. Unfortunately he is also very easily distracted and does not study, so he is failing my class. He chose to draw the map because it seemed the easier option. Since he had no idea what key components a map should have, he decided to make up for his lack of knowledge with creativity. Amir made the bold move of including me, "Mr. Nick," on his map. Not only did he highlight the fact that I got really sunburned at the last soccer game I coached (he drew a sun with rays that were labeled "cookin' Mr. Nick's face"), he also drew Miss Angel in a helicopter pulling Mr. Nick out of the window with a large magnet.
These essays provided a good laugh for me, and I hope they do the same for you.
